 | Tuesday, July 8, 2008
Issue 868 | | Will Smith, Editor |  |
|
Editor's Note: Today's top story is the second of a two-part series distilling the flurry of analysis by industry observers of Checkpoint's $37 million acquisition of OATSystems that was announced two weeks ago (see Checkpoint Buys OAT to Become One-Stop RFID Shop). Also be sure to see yesterday's RFID Industry Reaction to Checkpoint-OAT Deal, Part 1.
VentureBeat reports that InSync Software, a provider of RFID and sensor applications, has raised $3 million from previous investors Intel Capital, Rustic Canyon Partners, and Girish Gaitonde Living Trust. The Silicon Valley-based company last raised money in 2006, when it secured $7.5 million.
Lastly, OTA Training announced that its online RFID training is available at over 250 universities through Gatlin Education Services, a provider of web-based training to colleges and universities. |
|
RFID Industry Reaction to Checkpoint-OAT Deal, Part 2
Two weeks ago Checkpoint Systems, a leading provider of electronic article surveillance (EAS) and related anti-theft solutions to retailers, announced that it would acquire OATSystems, a pioneer in the middleware category that evolved into a provider of application- and vertical-specific RFID software (see Checkpoint Buys OAT to Become One-Stop RFID Shop). Not announced in the original release, the $37 million acquisition price was subsequently published in a Checkpoint filing. In the two weeks since the deal was announced, there has been a flurry of commentary about what it means for the players involved and the RFID industry at large. Following is the second of a two-part series featuring the best of that commentary. Also be sure to see yesterday's RFID Industry Reaction to Checkpoint-OAT Deal, Part 1.
The End of Middleware, Sort Of
OAT pioneered RFID "middleware," a moniker for the software that integrates RFID readers with the ERP system where the RFID data is ultimately stored. Depending on the particular product, middleware capabilities ranged from filtering, cleaning, and processing data, to managing a network of reader devices, to executing business logic against the data and events generated by the readers.
While all of these functions are no doubt valuable and necessary, most in the industry predicted that standalone software to perform them was overkill, and that eventually such functionality would be subsumed by ERP software from the likes of SAP, BEA, etc. For the last couple years, therefore, "middleware providers" as a category of RFID vendor was expected to simply go away as those companies either sold themselves, went out of business, or diversified or repositioned their offerings. And indeed, OAT's path -- evolving from pure middleware provider to vertical RFID software solution provider, then acquired by a much larger company -- seems to validate these predictions. As AMR's John Fontanella put it in his analysis of the deal, "OATSystems' fate was sealed from its inception."
Reik Read, the RFID industry financial analyst with Baird and author of RFID Monthly, was reluctant to call OAT's sale the absolute end of middleware because, he pointed out to RFID Update, "What these companies provide is certainly of value. The question is only what form that takes." That is, all of the historic functionality of RFID middleware will live on, but not in the standalone software packages it once did. Mike Liard of ABI Research calls it the end of the middleware category, not of middleware itself.
Behind the Scenes
According to industry sources, OAT was at a point to seek another round of funding from investors, who instead encouraged the company to explore a sale. Six companies were reportedly interested enough to bid for the company: Checkpoint, Zebra, Tyco ADT, Intermec, IBM, and Oracle. IBM and Oracle moved too slowly, say sources, and were not frontrunners in the bidding.
A couple years ago there had been strong speculation that IBM would acquire OAT. The two companies had partnered and were working together on numerous projects. Obviously that didn't come to pass. Liard surmises, "There was no urgency on IBM's side to make a strong move on OAT given the strength of the present relationship and complementary nature of the organizations and their offerings."
$37 Million. Is That a Lot?
Insiders tell RFID Update that OAT did between $3 and $5 million in revenue in 2007, which puts the acquisition price at around eight to ten times trailing revenue. (Note that the "soaking wet" price was closer to $45 million because of an additional $8 million for certain OAT leadership to incent them to stay on board.) An 8-10x valuation is good but not "off the charts," says one source. Ultimately, though, "the founders and VCs are happy."
Also important to note is that OAT could be on track to do $8 or $9 million this year, so the $45 million price likely had less to do with historic revenues and more to do with capturing growth. "All of the bidders were looking for market leadership and market vision, and a go-to-market capability," says one source. Revenues were secondary.
The First of Many?
Whenever a major RFID acquisition happens, the industry wonders if it marks the beginning of a trend. This time is no different. "Is this the start of a feeding frenzy?" wrote ODIN technologies CEO Patrick Sweeney on the company blog. "In a word - yes...Small and mid-cap companies who want to be serious players in the RFID industry will buy [RFID software and solutions providers] this year."
ABI's Liard acknowledged the possibility of more M&A, but noted that the industry's recent history told a different story: "Neither the 2004 acquisition of RFID innovator Matrics by Symbol (since acquired by Motorola) nor the 2005 acquisition of RFID software company Connecterra by BEA (since acquired by Oracle) triggered other acquisitions. Potential acquirers have to not only see a compelling need, but also be willing to make a sufficiently generous offer to convince the target company's investors."
Who Could Be Next
If more acquisitions were to occur, who are the likely targets? Think small, young companies that have carved out a strong niche and/or leadership position. Candidates would probably also have some sort of revenue-generating software offering since, if there is enough demand, selling software is a highly scalable and profitable business model. ODIN and Xterprise are possibilities. Liard also names Vue Technology, Acsis, and GlobeRanger. The latter is the last of the original "middleware" companies, though like OAT, it shed that classification well over a year ago and repositioned itself as an "edgeware" provider.
Conclusion
There appears to be industry consensus that Checkpoint's acquisition of OAT simply made sense. Checkpoint added much-needed software to its portfolio to fortify and expand its value proposition to retailers. OAT obtained financial security in the arms of an 800-million-dollar parent, while yielding its founders and investors a nice payday. And the middleware vendor category, long predicted to dissipate into other areas of the RFID value chain, finally did just that.
Forward this to a colleague | Request reprints: reprints at rfidupdate dot com |
|
|
|
|
| Products & Services | Automate your RFID Network
Reduce operating costs by 65% with patented EasyMonitor Software Service from ODIN technologies. For a few dollars a day, gain complete monitoring management system health and RF field optimization. EasyMonitor is operationally proven at 40+ sites worldwide with 99.5% uptime guaranteed. For information, visit ODIN technologies, or contact Kevin@ODINtechnologies.com for a live demonstration. | PCB Tracking & Visibility Solution from Omnitrol Networks
Off-the-shelf solution provides automated real-time visibility and complete electronic pedigree for traceability on parts and WIP providing real-time dashboards, alerts and reports for shop-floor management. The pedigree information is automatically programmed into Texas Instruments' RFID tag for access to critical data without the need for connection to a back-end database. Learn more. | Employees steal over $1 billion per week from employers
the American Management Association reports. 95% of businesses are victimized by employee theft. Managers are reluctant to ask questions, because trusted employees may feel offended, leaving business owners in a difficult situation. What can you do? Nox: Intelligent Perimeter Defense from Simply RFID provides advanced security and protection for business assets. | | | Upcoming Events | RFID World | Sept 8-10, 2008 | MGM Grand | Las Vegas, NV
Now in its 6th year, this industry leading event is recognized as the gathering place for the builders, buyers and sellers of RFID and other Auto-ID technologies. Registration now open! Special Early Bird Savings: Save $300 off registration. Offer ends July 31st. Don't miss out! | AWA PABS08 N. America Conference, Sept 11-12, Chicago, IL
AWA is organizing the Product Authentication & Brand Security Conference 2008 on September 11-12 in Chicago, IL. The event includes presentations and panel discussions with brand owners, legal authorities, associations, converters and suppliers; also networking sessions, a supplier forum, a social program and more. Find more on the program here. | AWA PABS08 Asia Conference, Dec 4-5 - Hong Kong, China
AWA presents the Asian Product Authentication & Brand Security Conference 2008, to be held on 4 & 5 December in Hong Kong, China. PABS08 Asia focuses on the threats specific to the Asia Pacific region, various elements of IP Theft, and leading-edge solutions. Find more on the program here. | | | RFID Tags & Labels | Ferroxtag HF tags: Smart on Metal!
Ferroxtag is a new family of HF RFID tags suitable for operation on metallic surfaces. Ferroxtag's special ferrite antenna was developed using Ferroxcube's years of experience in ferrite technology. The high performance antenna means longer read range with a smaller tag. Visit www.ferroxtag.com | | | RTLS & Active RFID | Locate it now. How? Ekahau. That's how!
Ekahau RTLS (Real-Time Location System) automatically tracks assets and people via your existing Wi-Fi network. Control costs and improve asset management with Ekahau. For more information, visit us at www.ekahau.com. | | | Employment | RFID Recruiters - 100% Focused on RFID Recruiting
Whether your company is looking for the best RFID talent or you have the best RFID talent and are looking for the best RFID employer, RFID Recruiters offers the most focused approach to your objective. To learn how the RFID industry and the RFID job market are evolving, visit www.rfidrecruiters.com | | | Research & Whitepapers | RFID Marketing Strategies Report
Thirty-nine pages of original research on RFID audience perceptions, including 30+ figures of tactics, content & messaging, and recommendations to guide marketing strategy. Also, Top-10 RFID company rankings based on 550+ survey respondents. View the executive summary free, with Top-3 sample rankings. Only $495 Individual License or $795 Corporate License. Available now |
This email was intended for , who subscribed
RFID Update is the RFID industry daily. Launched in early 2004 to provide timely analysis of RFID industry news, RFID Update publishes editorial briefings every weekday for the growing ranks of top level executives involved in the deployment of RFID. Each issue delivers the breaking news and analysis most pertinent to successful RFID implementations, allowing readers to understand global RFID developments as they happen.
RFID Update Editor: Will Smith, editor at rfidupdate dot com
Press releases and public relations inquiries should be directed to Will.
To advertise in RFID Update, email advertising08 at rfidupdate dot com to request a media kit.
RFID Questions? Ask at RFID Talk (www.RFIDtalk.com).
Forward this issue of RFID Update to your colleagues, or tell them to subscribe free at: www.RFIDupdate.com
View all past issues of RFID Update in the archive.
Update your subscription settings: subscriptions08 at rfidupdate dot com
We take your privacy seriously. View our Privacy Policy here.
RFID Update -- The RFID Industry Daily
3213 Duke Street #266
Alexandria, VA 22314
http://www.rfidupdate.com
© 2008, ALX Technologies. All Rights Reserved. |
|
|
